Required Return: Testing Stock Valuation Assumptions

Required return is not a prediction of what stocks will deliver. It is the criterion for asking whether today's price compensates sufficiently for time, alternatives, and risk.

Several return paths leading to the same business from different starting prices

The required return acts like a discount rate.

100 baht in five years is not worth the same as 100 baht today: today's money can be used or invested elsewhere, and the future is uncertain. Valuation models therefore discount future amounts to present value using required return.

The simplified formula is Present Value = Future Price ÷ (1 + Required Return)number of years With other assumptions fixed, a higher required return lowers the appropriate purchase price today

Same future value, different present values

Assume FCF or EPS and P/E model projects a future price of US$161.05 in five years. At required annual returns of 8%, 10%, and 12%, present values are approximately US$109.61, US$100.00, and US$91.38 respectively. These calculations use the displayed future price and round only the final amounts to two decimals.

The difference reflects investor criteria, not a business change. These figures exclude forecast errors, fees, taxes, and currency effects. Treat them as a testing starting point, not a buy instruction.

Check back without changing future prices.

At 8%, substitute 161.05 ÷ 1.08^5 ≈ 109.6079 then round to $109.61. At 10%, the result is about $99.9994, displayed as $100.00. The small difference comes from the future price shown to two decimals. Do not alter assumptions to force an exact fit.

This simplified formula considers only the price at the end of year five. Discount any intervening dividends or cash receipts separately under your chosen model. The terminal-price component alone is not the total value of every cash receipt. This example has no interim receipts and does not guarantee a future selling price.

How to choose a required rate of return

No rate fits every person and stock. Consider at least four factors:

Do not hide every risk inside Required Return

Raising the discount rate for every concern can obscure risk sources. Adjust specific assumptions instead: lower sales for uncertainty, lower margins for compression, and increase share counts for dilution. Then use a return requirement appropriate to remaining risks.

Do not lower the required return merely to make estimated value exceed market price; that reverses the formula to confirm a preferred belief

Use a range instead of one number

Try calculating at 8%, 10% and 12% or a range suitable for the case study. Then place it with the low, base and high growth cases. This table will tell you which assumptions the value depends on. If it takes maximum growth with minimum required returns to see upside, the model is fragile.

Then consider Margin of Safety additional allowance for errors outside the table, such as new competition, poor capital allocation, or unexpected events

Questions before recording results

  1. Is the rate nominal or inflation-adjusted, and are cash flows on the same basis?
  2. Which currency is used, and where are currency effects in the assumptions?
  3. Have you compared lower-risk alternatives and other portfolio assets?
  4. How does valuation change if the rate rises by 1–2 percentage points?
  5. Does required return reflect risk, or was it chosen to produce a preferred answer?

Document where your required return comes from, use a basis consistent with the cash flows, and test how changing the rate affects value. When markets or risks change, you can revisit the original reasoning and update the assumptions using the available information.

Related toolsSee the effect of Required Return on the purchase price.Try changing the desired rate of return. Then compare the purchase price using FCF and EPS and P/E methods.

Sources

This article provides general information and an example model. It is not a target return or individual securities trading recommendation.